Why is it that when television
and film production companies decide to adapt a nineteenth century novel it
tends to be either Charles Dickens or Jane Austen?
I know there has been
countless adaptations of Frankenstein,
Sherlock Holmes and Dracula, but in most cases, they stray
from the originals outrageously that they are almost not worth one’s notice
here. And to notice them would only add
weight to my argument anyway.
The countless Dickens and
Austen adaptions there have been have kept closely to the originals. And when they do adapt Dickens, it is usually
the same half dozen or so.
If adapting a period drama
they should broaden their horizons.
Mary Braddon and Ellen
Wood equalled Dickens in sales and popularity (and possibly eclipsed him, if
truth were told). If either of them are
adapted, they rather lazily opt for Lady
Audley’s Secret or East Lynne.
I am really surprised no
one has bothered to adapt Benjamin Disraeli’s Coningsby or Sybil, for
instance. Not only are they powerful
dramas and fluffy romances, but the satire is savage and sophisticated and the
humour hilarious.
Likewise the tales and
novels of Joseph Sheridan Le Fanu. If
you ignore the trifles concerning leprechauns and fairies, much of his other
works would make brilliantly dark dramas and sparkling comedies.
And as for Maria
Edgeworth, isn’t it about time someone adapted her Castle Rackrent, or Ennui?
I am sure many an actress
would kill to portray a character like troubled socialite Lady Delacoeur or independent-minded
Belinda Portman, from Belinda. Both of them are groundbreaking characters;
one for making breast cancer a central feature and topical subject in a romance
novel; and the other for seriously contemplating an inter-racial marriage as
late or early as pre-emancipation 1801 (more groundbreaking, however, was the
inter-racial marriage between a footman and a maid, which the author played
down as to be practically an insignificant incident hardly worth notice except
as perhaps a binary opposition to the central characters).
I could add other authors
to this, but I have already exceeded the word length.
No comments:
Post a Comment